Buku “Memodernisasi Pertanian Indonesia” oleh CIPS: Rekomendasi Penghapusan Kebijakan Subsidi Pupuk oleh Pemerintah Pusat

 


Dalam buku “Memodernisasi Pertanian Indonesia” dari Center for Indonesian Policy Studies (CIPS) @cips_id terdapat Bab khusus yang membahas mengenai perlu beralihnya kebijakan subsidi pupuk dan benih dari pemerintah pusat/Kementan @kemenkopangan.ri @kementerianpertanian menjadi kebijakan yang lebih produktif dan efisien.

Dan salah satu rekomendasi kebijakan yang diusulkan yaitu mengganti kebijakan subsidi pupuk dan “beralih menjadi pembayaran langsung yang dilakukan melalui Kartu Tani”. Hal ini pula yang ingin saya teliti melalui Riset Tesis saya tentang Kebijakan Hibah Kartu Tani Sibedas di Kabupaten Bandung yang menerapkan mekanisme mirip seperti yang CIPS usulkan. Pada tesis yang sedang saya garap saya pun menekankan tentang Resiliensi Petani Padi melalui Pendekatan Penghidupan Berkelanjutan seperti yang dibahas pada buku ini di Bab sebelumnya.

Semoga hasil Riset Tesis saya kedepan bisa menjadi masukan yang berarti mengenai alternatif kebijakan dan intervensi pemerintah untuk meningkatkan kesejahteraan petani.

Hal lain yang juga saya soroti adalah harus digantinya indikator NTP (Nilai Tukar Petani) menjadi Indeks Kesejahteraan Petani yang lebih kompleks dan menyeluruh agar kebijakan pemerintah tidak terjebak pada indikator yang kurang merepresentasikan kondisi dan kebutuhan riil petani di lapangan.

Semoga saya bisa terus belajar dan menyumbangkan ide mengenai hal ini, sesuai dengan konsentrasi saya di Magister Ekonomi Pertanian Faperta UNPAD @ekper_unpad @s2ekperunpad23ganjil @fapertaunpad__ @universitaspadjadjaran yaitu Pembangunan dan Kebijakan Pertanian.

Teman-teman bisa mengorder e-Book dari buku “Memodernisasi Pertanian Indonesia” ini di Google Play Book ya.

Selamat membaca dan mengkaji!

 

@tuti.karyani @dwiartamaangga @iw.an_s @lies_indratto @trisnanoor @eka_yudha81 @agriventure18 @agumrestualam @ramdannnnn

Reflection from “Supermarket USA” Book: “What is the Most Sustainable Food System of Our Generation?”

 

Shane Hamilton’s “Supermarket USA: Food and Power in the Cold War Farms Race” explores the intricate relationship between American supermarkets, agricultural policies, and Cold War dynamics. In the Introduction, Hamilton posits that supermarkets served as symbols of capitalist abundance, showcasing the superiority of American economic systems over socialist counterparts. He introduces the concept of the “Cold War Farms Race,” emphasizing that agricultural productivity became a critical battleground in the ideological conflict between capitalism and communism. The author argues that while supermarkets were perceived as embodiments of free enterprise, they were fundamentally supported by significant state investment in agricultural technology and infrastructure.

Chapter 1, titled “Machines for Selling,” focuses on the Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company (A&P), which was a dominant force in the supermarket industry during the mid-20th century. Hamilton illustrates how A&P’s distribution system exemplified American abundance, contrasting it with the scarcity experienced in socialist countries. The chapter highlights A&P’s operational strategies and their implications for consumer access to food, reinforcing the political messages associated with capitalist success. In Chapter 2, “The Farms Race Begins,” he examines the rise of industrial agriculture in the U.S., detailing how government policies and technological advancements facilitated this growth, thereby supporting supermarket expansion and countering communist ideologies.

The subsequent chapters delve into the global implications of American supermarkets. Chapter 3, “Supermercado USA,” discusses how U.S. supermarket models were exported as tools of economic influence in foreign markets, while Chapter 4 contrasts American supermarkets with socialist grocery systems, highlighting ideological battles over consumerism. Chapter 5, “Food Chains and Free Enterprise,” explores the complex relationships within food supply chains, revealing how supermarkets shaped agricultural practices and rural economies. Finally, Chapter 6, “Food Power and the Global Supermarket,” addresses how American supermarkets became instruments of U.S. foreign policy, promoting not just economic interests but also cultural values associated with capitalism. The Epilogue reflects on the lasting legacy of supermarkets as powerful symbols of economic power and consumer culture that shaped international food systems during and after the Cold War.

Recommend to read!

 

After I read “Supermarket USA” Book by Shane Hamilton, I am thinking about transformational change in American Agriculture from we call “traditional agriculture” to become “Agribusiness”. In the mid 60s, America had surplus in main commodity because of the advancement of agricultural technology.

The idea to absorb the surplus in the farmer’s harvest was between regulate by the government or let the supply and demand did it’s part with Free Enterprise and Private Sector role. The option that chosen was the free enterprise and private sector took the role to let the supply and demand played it’s magic, and from here “Supermarket” took a big part as a tool and propaganda of abundance of food for all of Americans and the world against the Communism.

The “Supermarket” created the term of “Consumer Sovereignty” that gave the consumer goods and products in affordable price and many options of it. The journey was continued to make the supply chain and market price efficient and effective with created bigger and merged retail chain, so merging of small retailer and aggregator was something a must on that period. It created the oligopsony and oligopoly retail chain until now, and it expanded to global market also other countries followed the steps.

Today, the supermarket, like Walmart and Amazon, is the leading enterprise in the world with the most sophisticated technology and system. But the critics say, it make our food should come from far away from our location create the term “food from nowhere”. So the latest movement is appeared to counter the issues, like Community Supported Agriculture (CSA), short food supply chain, city gardening, local community of agricultural products, even gardening in front of our yard.

Let’s see and make a research how to create the most sustainable way of our food system.. I hope I can get the answer immediately.. InsyaAllah..